The Peru Gazette

Telegraph Rd. south of the Sullivan Rd. intersection

Temporary repairs on Cook Rd.

2019 Patent Rd.

Closed Telegraph Rd. Culvert

Telegraph Rd. culvert sink-hole

By John T Ryan 

Peru –  $5 million+ is a lot of money in a small town; however, that’s the approximate amount Peru incurred or will soon incur for its culvert replacement projects (not including any long-term borrowing costs). Town officials hoped that Peru would qualify for grants under the Bridge NY program; however, it doesn’t appear that will happen. Town Supervisor Brandy McDonald commented, “Like always, we are checking with Assemblyman Billy Jones to see if there is any chance of getting any funding from the State. We’re looking into anything possible for funding.” McDonald said the town would look at long-term borrowing if that effort fails. 

Highway Department Superintendent Michael Farrell recalls former Highway Department Superintendent Elmer Duprey telling him the culvert failures would happen under his watch. Duprey headed the department when the historic 1996 and 1998 floods washed out several culverts. The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) declared Peru a disaster area and funded the replacement culverts. Elmer Duprey recalls, “I wanted to use concrete box culverts, not galvanized pipe, but FEMA said ‘no.’ They insisted that we use what had been in place before the flooding. I knew galvanized pipe had changed over the years. It doesn’t hold up like it once did.” 

Environmental stream quality and fish habitat laws and regulations laws have also changed. Today, the U.S. Army Corp of Engineers and the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) typically mandate that towns use box culverts.* While box culverts are guaranteed to last up to 100 years, they are costly. The town will pay $129,000 for the relatively small box culvert installed on Cook Rd. Culvert replacement projects also have design, engineering, and contracting costs. 

Recent and pending Peru projects: 

• 2019 Patent Rd. $264,000 
• 2022 Telegraph Rd. – Sullivan Road Intersection – Estimated $2 million 
• 2024 (Pending) Telegraph Rd. – Estimated $1,500,000 
• 2024 (Ongoing) Cook Rd. – $340,000
• (Pending) Wescott Rd in Peasleeville, a larger culvert than the pending culvert on Telegraph Rd. 

*Thank you to the NYS DEC for the following information regarding culverts and streams. 

Stream crossing applications are individually reviewed against the standards in the applicable statutes and regulations such as Environmental Conservation Law section 15-0501 Protection of Streams, 6NYCRR Part 608 Use and Protection of Waters, Clean Water Act Section 401 Water Quality Certification, and the Community Risk and Resiliency Act. DEC’s stream crossing guidelines are outlined here: Stream Crossings – NYSDEC. Characteristics such as stream width and slope at the specific stream/crossing dictate the required structures. 

The statewide General Permit for stream activities also contains information on the types of culvert projects we recommend: General Permit For Stream Activities, GP-0-20-002 – NYSDEC. DEC’s Protection of Waters webpage provides additional information: Protection of Waters Program – NYSDEC.